07 November 2026

Against the Starmaster news

Against the Darkmaster (VsD) is one of my favourite role-playing games of the 21st Century (matched only by Mythras). I’m currently running a long-term campaign for it (it’s been going on for over three years now) and recently ran a two-year campaign set in Middle-earth (information for both campaigns are available via links on the righthand side of this blog). While VsD is clearly inspired – mechanically and thematically – by ICE’s Middle-earth Roleplaying (MERP) RPG from the 1980s and 1990s (it’s easy to use old MERP material with VsD), it’s nonetheless not a “retro-clone” as it modifies many elements of MERP and introduces some of its own mechanics, perhaps the most impactful being “drive points” and associated “heroic paths.” 

Since I’ve posted quite a bit about VsD already, I won’t continue rambling about it now. But I mention it because the producers of VsD – Open Ended Games (OEG) – are developing a game that uses the VsD rules but adapts them for the “space opera” genre (the original Star Wars trilogy appears to be a primary inspiration). I’ve mentioned this RPG – called (appropriately enough) Against the Starmaster – here before. But I mention it again now because there are some new developments that I thought might be of interest to some readers.


First, a new version of the playtest ruleset is available here. The picture above is taken from the sample adventure. 

Second, there is an interview with the game’s lead designer Massimiliano Caracristi at Geek Native.

Finally, a Kickstarter campaign for VsS starts on 23 November 2026 (link). I backed the Kickstarter campaign for Secrets of the Golden Throne, and Open Ended Games did a great job in fulfilling that project, so I have full confidence that the Kickstarter process will help support an excellent final rulebook.

For what it’s worth, here is my very brief review of the playtest rules (which I previously posted on DrivethruRPG):

An excellent adaptation of the Against the Darkmaster rules to the space opera genre. 

Against the Starmaster (VsS) employs a straightforward unified mechanic: roll 1d100 and add/subtract modifiers. But rolls can “explode” at the extremes, leading to “open ended” results (i.e., an unmodified roll of 1-5 prompts a second roll that is subtracted from that amount; an unmodified roll of 96-100 prompts a second roll that is added to that amount; etc.). These can produce wonderfully unpredictable and memorable outcomes in play, as extreme successes or failures differ from standard successes or failures. 

For characters, VsS is a skill-based system, wherein skill selection and progression is organised via “vocations” (rogue, champion, mystic, etc.) and levels. There are a lot of charts (the system is a descendant in many ways of RPGs like MERP, Rolemaster, and Spacemaster). However, in VsS these are clear and easy to use. The critical strike charts are vivid and colourful. (E.g., the most lethal result for “Blast”: “A cataclysmic shockwave rips the target apart. Death is immediate and violent. Nothing remains but ash. Need a dustpan?”)

While the combat system can be brutal, “drive points” can be used by players to reroll certain results. Acting on the characters' “passions” can replenish such points. So while combat is dangerous, the heroes have resources – albeit limited in nature (no more than 5 drive points can be accumulated at any given time) – to engage in actions of derring-do.

There is no system quite like it out there today. Highly recommended!

(Note that these are the playtest rules. So rules on character creation, etc., are not included. However, a number of pre-generated characters are provided, as is an introductory adventure.)

Overall, and especially with respect to role-playing games, I generally am much more of a fan of the fantasy genre than I am of pulpy space opera. So, part of me wishes that OEG’s focus had remained on producing more VsD material (e.g., a bestiary, more adventures, perhaps a proper setting book) instead of a different game. Nonetheless, variety is the spice of life, and having looked at the rules, I now anticipate someday running a VsS campaign for a change of pace. The first two Star Wars films (and especially The Empire Strikes Back) remain favourites of mine. And even though I think that most Star Wars movies and shows have been rubbish after 1980 (Return of the Jedi is barely tolerable), both Rogue One and Andor were excellent. (I also quite like the Dune films, another inspiration cited for the rules.) So, I can see the appeal of a campaign of high adventure involving some plucky and determined rebels against a galaxy-spanning evil imperial order!

7 comments:

  1. Another article on VsS: https://www.rascal.news/space-opera-ttrpg-against-the-starmaster-comes-to-kickstarter-this-november/

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love the conceit of the darkmaster/starmaster as an ultimate evil remaining off-stage but affecting the course of the adventure. Back in the day I admired the Shadow World products, they always seemed so transgressive and alien compared to the material coming out of TSR. I'm curious if that was the material you were using while playing Rolemaster, or maybe you leaned more towards MERP? Thanks for sharing the news, i'm tempted kickstart this if only to support the distant antagonist backdrop for this game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Back in the day, I primarily used ICE's Middle-earth materials and used that setting for my campaigns. I started with the MERP system and then integrated elements of Rolemaster. I ran a few "proper" RM 2e games but ultimately preferred the balance provided by MERP in play. About 25 years ago I tried running RMSS but found it to be too much. I think MERP/VsD is at my "comfort level" in terms of rules heaviness (or "crunch" -- if that term is still in use).

      I have a decent amount of Shadow World material in my collection (focused mainly on the continent of "Jaiman") but never actually used the setting. I do find myself borrowing some things from SW for my own world ("Ukrasia") in my current campaign.

      (P.S. Good to hear from you again!)

      Delete
  3. I must admit that as I get older, i care less and less for rules granularity. I do like the open-ended rolls of VsD though, since it offers the possibility of some dramatic in-game results. I still own the 1994 MERP Moria adventure, but my collection of MERP/RM is otherwise pretty thin. I'm hoping the Starmaster kickstarter will have an optional VsD component; I went looking for some VsD rules after I read your post but it is apparently out-of-print. Good connecting with you too, my life's been busy, but my blog ... not so much!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The VsD rules are available (POD and PDF) at DrivethruRPG!
      But they are divided into the Player's Handbook (https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/401318/against-the-darkmaster-player-s-handbook) and the GM's Guide (https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/488077/against-the-darkmaster-game-master-s-guide?src=hottest_filtered).
      The PHB and GMG cover all the rules from the big "core book". The only thing missing is the sample campaign ("Shadows of the Northern Woods"), although that's available as a PDF on DTRPG (https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/329327/shadows-of-the-northern-woods?src=hottest_filtered).

      Delete
  4. I don't see anything there for print-on-demand. When I was talking to my FLGS, VsD was once in-print but is no longer available for them to order. That's a shame!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The PHB and GMG are *definitely* available print-on-demand. I received POD versions of them quite recently.
      https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/401318/against-the-darkmaster-player-s-handbook

      Beneath the PDF option are the POD options.

      The core book (which includes the rules from both the PHB and GMG) is only available in PDF form DrivethruRPG. Perhaps that is the version you checked. That’s the version that is out of print. (A copy was available at “Sword and Board in Toronto last time I checked.)

      Delete